PuTTY vulnerability private-key-not-wiped

Home | Licence | FAQ | Docs | Download | Keys | Links
Mirrors | Updates | Feedback | Changes | Wishlist | Team

summary: Private keys left in memory after being used by PuTTY tools
class: vulnerability: This is a security vulnerability.
difficulty: fun: Just needs tuits, and not many of them.
priority: high: This should be fixed in the next release.
absent-in: r1020
present-in: 0.52 0.53 0.53b 0.54 0.55 0.56 0.57 0.58 0.59 0.60 0.61 0.62
fixed-in: r9988 bf9b9224d8325d63513efef547857983a6f145e5 2013-07-14 0.63

When PuTTY has sensitive data in memory and has no further need for it, it should wipe the data out of its memory, in case malware later gains access to the PuTTY process or the memory is swapped out to disk or written into a crash dump file. An obvious example of this is the password typed during SSH login; other examples include obsolete session keys, public-key passphrases, and the private halves of public keys.

After loading an RSA key, PuTTY runs the internal routine rsa_verify() to check that it makes sense. Every version of PuTTY since 2001, up to and including 0.62, has a bug in which rsa_verify() fails to wipe from memory two large integer variables containing p−1 and q−1, where p and q are the two primes whose product is the RSA key modulus. Recovering these from a PuTTY memory image would be sufficient to reconstruct the private half of the RSA key; so those versions of PuTTY would effectively store your private key in memory for as long as they were running.

Similar problems apply to DSA keys: PuTTY fails to free the private key component x, and also does not free the random number k that it generates when making a DSA signature, possession of which is sufficient to expose the private key.

This applies to every program in the PuTTY suite which loads private keys: PuTTY, PSCP, PSFTP and Plink. If any of those programs loads a private key directly (rather than getting a signature from an SSH agent such as Pageant) then they will have left information equivalent to the private key in memory for their entire run.

Pageant also had the same bug, but of course since its job is to retain decrypted private keys in memory that isn't important in most cases. However, if you ever told Pageant to delete a key from memory, it would not have properly deleted it: it would still have retained a copy by mistake due to this bug.

PuTTY 0.63 fixes this bug in all the tools: those variables are now correctly wiped from memory.

However, it is still unavoidably very dangerous if malicious software is in a position to read the memory of your PuTTY processes: there is still a lot of sensitive data in there which cannot be wiped because it's still being used, e.g. session keys. And, as mentioned above, Pageant retains decrypted private keys in memory for long periods on purpose if you use it. So this fix somewhat mitigates the risks of malicious access to your PuTTY processes' memory, but no fix can eliminate those risks completely.

The RSA part of this vulnerability was spotted by Coverity Scan.

This bug has been assigned CVE ID CVE-2013-4208.

If you want to comment on this web site, see the Feedback page.
Audit trail for this vulnerability.
(last revision of this bug record was at 2016-12-27 11:40:21 +0000)