ID card rollout begins
Ian Batten
ukcrypto at chiark.greenend.org.uk
Fri, 26 Sep 2008 09:16:47 +0100
[[ ob.crypto: I've not been seeing my own postings to this list. A
poke around reveals that I'd managed to configure DKIM so that my own
server couldn't retrieve its own public key, so I was bouncing mail
which my server had signed. And they say that crypto-enabling of mail
systems is easy. ]]
On 26 Sep 08, at 0756, Roland Perry wrote:
> In article <492CC2D6-7DD0-4AE3-BB1A-35EC475E19D6@batten.eu.org>, Ian
> Batten <igb@batten.eu.org> writes
>> It's the Poll Tax, but with no winners.
>
> Although if the cards announced yesterday allowed travel within the
> EEA (and re-entry to the UK without a passport or landing card), the
> holders would be "winners" to that extent.
It's not easy to see how, or why, the UK government can issue travel
documents over its own authority which permit non UK-citizens to
travel simply on the basis that the holder is a legal resident in the
UK. I'm pretty sure Schengen free-movement rules apply to citizens,
not residents: does a US citizen with residence rights in France have
automatic right of entry into Germany? And if they do, it's hard to
think of a more convincing reason to ensure that a party that proposed
that the UK joins Schengen will be committing electoral suicide.
There are mechanisms by which country X can issue travel documents for
citizens of country Y which might be acceptable in country Z, but they
mostly apply to refugees and stateless persons.
ian